Fables Vol 18 Cubs in Toyland Graphic Novel Review

Fables Vol 18 Cubs in ToylandErica gives this comic three starsFables Vol 18 Cubs in Toyland by Bill Willingham
Art: Mark Buckingham, Steve Leialoha, Gene Ha, Andrew Pepoy, and Dan Green

I have big mixed feelings about this volume. Willingham seems to be greatly enjoying having his own characters — the seven cubs of Bigby and Snow — to do as he wishes with them. I wonder if he’s felt that the rule he created early on, about characters being given immortality and inability to be killed based on fairy tale popularity, has greatly limited what he can do when it comes to audience pain. You know, he’s no Joss Whedon.

Leigh and her sidestory just seemed to be an overall distraction. I’m not sure where Willingham is going with it, and I’m not entirely sure he currently knows. As much as I’m sure whatever revenge Leigh has planned will be insidious, she’s just not as scary as Dark Man.

I must admit that until this story, the Cubs had largely run together for me. I mean, sure Ghost stands out. But the rest of them were kind of blur as Snow and Bigby’s children.

In a way, both Therese and Darien are punished for their pretty typical childish ways. Therese for being a selfish brat and Darien for ignoring his siblings and craving adventure. Ambrose was probably the only one completely unfairly punished with the visions.

The toys themselves having this sort of punishment seemed absurd. It’s not like they lit children’s rooms on fire or made them swallow pieces. And seriously, did they not think to bring food after the other children died?

I really couldn’t handle it when Lord Mountbatten died, even though it showed Therese hitting rock bottom and becoming an evil queen in need of full redemption herself. I think it almost bothered me more than Darien putting himself on his own sword. Which I had to read about four times as everything was slightly too off stage. I suppose I’m glad that they didn’t kill each other.

I did appreciate that everyone was redeemed in the end. That ultimately Therese found her goodness and that in the toys, and that she did get to go home to tell Snow what happened. I am interested to see what happens to Winter, and if Willingham will make a female character that powerful in his universe.

Learn about the cubs and buy Fables Vol. 18: Cubs in Toyland.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.