Stargate: Vala Mal Doran Comic Miniseries Review

Stargate: Vala Mal Doran Miniseries

Erica gives this comic three starsStargate: Vala Mal Doran by Brandon Jerwa

I’ll start off by saying that Vala is one of my favorite characters of all time who appeared on a rather mediocre show that I am not a big fan of. I’m incredibly picky about how Vala is portrayed and how she is respected. I’m very pleased to have read this comic book miniseries and say that yes, Jerwa stayed true to her character and gave a balanced view of her bad traits and her good ones.

Then why only three stars? The plot didn’t grab me in a way I’d hoped and the artwork. Oh, the artwork. While it wasn’t offensive in all the ways I find myself often offended by comic books (read excessive t&a and twinkle-toes), I found it bland. In the way that I unfortunately find a lot of comic books that tie-into TV shows have bland artwork. I don’t know if they’re afraid to experiment or what, but Razek gives me bland characters who look somewhere between the actors portraying them and their action figures.

Jerwa’s plot wanted to be clever, and at points, there were things I didn’t see coming. It was all very Stargate: SG-1. And perhaps that was the exact problem. This was very much like the episode with the Lucian Alliance. There was a long trail of twists and turns, and as in her typical pre-SG-1 days, Vala betrayed those who were “helping” her and got SG-1 into trouble.

The only twist I did not see coming was that Vala was initially trying to do good by stopping the plant. I was still a little confused why she was hired to start with; as it was hidden in the middle of the jail, the plant seemed to be pretty protected without the ability to turn everyone into its slaves.

I do think Jerwa relied too much on the “Daniel loves Vala and thinks she worthwhile so he’s going to keep telling that to everyone” shtick. While I think it’s perfectly Stargate canon to do so, it’s one of my personal pet peeves from the show.

But one thing I loved and appreciated about the entire comic was Vala saving herself. Even as Cam and Teal’c try to help her at the end, only Vala makes her plan work and kills the assassin and evil plant. I approve.

This comic did make me want to rewatch some of my favorite scenes with Vala, and those episodes where she stood out and had fun. I’m glad that I picked up this comic book as my issues with Stargate (particularly it’s writing staff and how Atlantis was canceled) are plenty, but Jerwa reminded me of what I liked about the universe, particularly one of my all-time favorite characters Val Mal Doran.

Buy Stargate: Vala Mal Doran by Brandon Jerwa and Cezar Razek.

2 Replies to “Stargate: Vala Mal Doran Comic Miniseries Review”

  1. I like your comment about Vala. I was addicted to the TV show – even as “campy” and predictable as it was. I envisioned Vala as a leading and edgy character that was always hiting a social “glass ceiling” that somehow was being eluded by Samantha since she was so much more the lead geek. Vala’s insights into the personalities of people and how to exploit them or defeat them (depending on the viewpoint) was part of the excitement – you could not be entirely sure how she would act or react next. This was somewhat juxtaposed to the normally predictable nature of the show as the predictability was twisted when she was the focal point.

    1. Thanks. Those are such great points about why Vala is so awesome. Yes, she did provide a good twist on the normal predictability of Stargate SG-1. (And I loved Sam, but for different reasons.) Vala certainly brought a lot of excitement to the show.

Leave a Reply to Erica Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *